I am a teacher. I am on my feet most of the day and need comfortable shoes. I also can't afford to spend a lot of money on a luxury purchase without a good reason. Because I need comfort, I have been buying Rockport shoes for years. However, I was sick of having to replace each pair every year to year and a half. Further, while I don't want to be too dressy (I'm a teacher and wearing a suit and tie everyday would be out of place), I do want to bring my look up from the business casual (sometimes on the most casual end of "business" casual) that I've done the past few years since I want to move into administration (the old "dress for the job you want" idea). So, I needed to get some nice dress shoes to go with the sport coat or blazer and chinos combo that I've moved to (sometimes with, sometimes without a tie), and most Rockport dress shoes don't look very dressy. I knew from experience that Bostonians or Florsheims might be pushing it on comfort if I'm always on my feet, and from what I've been reading, their quality has really gone downhill. Also, I have a hard to fit EEE to EEEE foot. From online reviews, it seemed that Johnston and Murphy or Allen Edmonds might be the way to go for nice dressy shoes that are still comfortable and available in wide widths, and I like that the Allen Edmonds, while not much more than the J&Ms, are made in America. So, I decided to give them a try.
While I have read reviews from people who have had their Allen Edmonds shoes for many years or even a decade or more, I cannot comment on durability or longevity since I've only had these shoes for a few days. However, I can comment on other aspects of the purchase.
First, quality to the degree I can ascertain at this point (workmanship and materials) appears to be as good as I expected from all the reviews I've read. You can tell from the stitching, and the look, smell and feel of the leather that these shoes are in a totally different league from shoes from Florsheim or Bostonian. They look and feel quite solid.
Comfort, for new, unbroken-in shoes they are incredibly comfortable. Since I've been wearing Rockport, they are a little tight on the top of my foot (not in the width) because this style shoe fits tighter that what I've been used to (but they aren't uncomfortable, I just need to get used to real dress shoes again). Otherwise, they felt terrific- plenty of cushioning for my feet and easily wide enough for my very wide feet.
Style...I love cap toe dress shoes. When I worked in business, that and wingtips were all I bought. They look terrific! If I don't polish them to too shiny a polish I can even just barely get away with wearing them with jeans.
So, on a teacher's budget were they worth the cost? Well, I've gone and ordered a pair of Allen Edmonds McTavish wingtips in cognac. If they last less than half as long as I expect them to from all the reviews they will still be a bargain.
Edit: Just a quick update: 2 years later and they still look new. They are definitely durable, long-lasting shoes.
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
From the manufacturer
The Park Avenue Cap-toe Oxford
Handcrafted in Port Washington, WI, with premium European calfskin leather, the recraftable Park Avenue cap-toe oxford is built on our original 360 Goodyear Bench Welt, providing stability and our legendary lasting comfort. Sleek, classic and so versatile, the Park Avenue is our very best-selling style. With a classic fit and clean lines, it can be dressed up, worn business casual or styled with your laid-back looks.
"I've been wearing Allen Edmonds shoes for over 30 years. they are a terrific price/value purchase. Fit, style and construction are all top quality." - Hugh
Find the Right Size
What makes Allen Edmonds shoes so unique is the extensive range of sizes and widths we offer that make achieving a perfect fit much simpler. Each half size increases by approximately one-sixth of an inch and each full size increases by one-third of an inch. The widths of Allen Edmonds shoes range from AAA, the narrowest width, to EEE, the widest width, with a D width considered medium. Technically speaking, each width increases by approximately three-sixteenths of an inch in total girth.
Reviews with images
Not what I expected!! Not true, as to what was Advertised.
I had previously purchased a pair of Oxblood Allen Edmunds Park Avenue shoes, and they are fantastic. This time, I wanted to purchase a pair of Black Allen Edmunds Park Avenue shoes. If you look at picture you will notice something missing...Shoelaces. Also, notice the broguing. The Park Avenue model shown in the picture on the site is a Cap Toe, with NO broguing. Lastly, my previous shoes came in an Allen Edmunds shoebox, and cloth shoe bags. These shoes were just wrapped in tissue paper, loose inside the shipping box. When you spend $400+ on a pair of shoes, you expect the correct model, shoelaces, and better packaging..SMH
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
Reviewed in the United States on August 29, 2014
Reviewed in the United States on September 11, 2012
Reviewed in the United States on May 15, 2012
Top reviews from other countries
Sam
I love the old school American looks
Reviewed in Canada on April 23, 2022Size: 8.5Color: MahoganyVerified Purchase
West Coast Sherpa
Factory seconds, multiple imperfections
Reviewed in Canada on March 26, 2022Size: 8.5Color: Dark Chili BurnishedVerified Purchase
CanadianBoy
These are used and factory seconds
Reviewed in Canada on September 29, 2021Size: 11Color: CoffeeVerified Purchase
Jason
Awful! Looks like a factory second.
Reviewed in Canada on December 14, 2020
Jason
Reviewed in Canada on December 14, 2020
Images in this review
Scott
Highly Recommended
Reviewed in Canada on July 27, 2020Size: 13 Women/11 MenColor: BlackVerified Purchase
