Florsheim Men's, Berkeley Penny Loafer

4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars 949 ratings
Price: $96.88 $129.95 Free Returns on some sizes and colors
Free 7-day try-on available for some sizes and colors.
Free shipping & returns. Learn more

Black
Size Chart
US Shoe Width (Medium/D)
Brand SizeUS SizeShoe Width (in)
5.55.53.2
663.5
6.56.54
773.6
7.57.53.6
883.7
8.58.53.8
993.8
9.59.53.9
10103.9
10.510.54
11114.1
11.511.54.1
12124.2
13134.2
14144.4
15154.5
16164.6
US Shoe Width (Wide/3E)
Brand SizeUS SizeShoe Width (in)
5.55.53.5
664
6.56.54.1
774.1
7.57.54.2
884.2
8.58.54.3
994.4
9.59.54.4
10104.5
10.510.54.6
11114.6
11.511.54.1
12124.8
13134.9
14145
15155.1
16165.2

Product details

Fabric type
100% Leather
Care instructions
Machine Wash
Origin
Imported
Sole material
Manmade

About this item

  • Genuine handsewn moccasin construction with a premium leather upper
  • Leather sourced from a tannery with a Gold or Silver rating for environmental responsibility
  • Penny-loafer styling for a classic look
  • Unlined shoe
  • Foam cushioned footbed for all-day comfort
To buy, select Size

From the manufacturer

About Us

In 1892 Florsheim Shoes started in a small factory in Chicago, Illinois. We’ve grown quite a bit since then being at the forefront of the trends, styling and quality workmanship. From material selection to stitching, we pay attention to the smallest details because we know you care just as much as we do.

Product details

  • Product Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 10 x 15 x 6 inches; 15 ounces
  • Item model number ‏ : ‎ 17058-01
  • Department ‏ : ‎ mens
  • Date First Available ‏ : ‎ May 15, 2008
  • Manufacturer ‏ : ‎ Florsheim
  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0010C8RT8
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.1 4.1 out of 5 stars 949 ratings

Product Description

A timeless classic, the penny loafer never goes out of style. Featuring genuine handsewn construction, stacked heel, and a genuine leather sole, whether it's with a suit or jeans, the Florsheim Berkley Moc Toe Penny Loafer has a rich look that is sure to get noticed.

Simply the standard, Florsheim’s Berkley penny loafer is a must-have part of your footwear collection. Paired with workday suiting or alongside khakis, no socks, this slip-on is a fashion warrior that always looks great and is never out of place. Its buffed leather has great finish, a leather outsole lends refinement, and a rubber-enforced heel adds durability and tames heel strikes for greater comfort.

Looking for specific info?

Top Brand: Florsheim

Highly Rated
50K+ customers rate items from this brand highly
Trending
10K+ orders for this brand in past 3 months
Low Returns
Customers usually keep items from this brand

Customer reviews

4.1 out of 5 stars
4.1 out of 5
949 global ratings

Customers say

Customers like the appearance, comfort, and quality of the shoes. For example, they mention that it looks real nice, it's shiny, and it doesn't bother while walking. That said, opinions are mixed on fit, durability, and value.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

77 customers mention77 positive0 negative

Customers are satisfied with the quality of the shoes. They mention that they are great, comfortable, and perfect. Some customers also say that the toe box is good. Overall, most are happy with the product's quality and design.

"Great classic design, comfortable, fits my husbands ‘ feet perfectly." Read more

"...They must be working for a competitor of something. These are very good shoes. Florsheim is best IMO, which is why I have worn them for decades...." Read more

"...That was really smooth. But the shoe is great, comfortable and gives him stability when he has to walk on one leg. Thanks." Read more

"Great shoe, comfortable, elegant, leather.I live outside the United States and they arrived very well" Read more

63 customers mention47 positive16 negative

Customers like the comfort of the shoes. They mention that they are very comfortable, and seem to fit true to size. Some say that the shoes are an exceptional comfortable fit, although a bit stiff at first. Overall, most are satisfied with the comfort and color of the product.

"Great classic design, comfortable, fits my husbands ‘ feet perfectly." Read more

"Like 👍👌 more comfortable then flex brown wood taps sound..." Read more

"...Once properly molded to your foot, these shoes are incomparable in comfort, more like wearing a ballet slipper than a dress shoe...." Read more

"...These shoes have no cushion in the sole at all and are extremely painful for me to wear. I don't know how Michael wore them all day." Read more

62 customers mention56 positive6 negative

Customers are satisfied with the appearance of the shoes. They mention that it looks real nice, is shiny, sturdy, and has the real leather soul and heel. Some say that the colors run.

"These are the real deal! They are shiny, sturdy, have the real leather soul and heel which sound great walking down the hall and they fit great...." Read more

"They look nice but are hard and uncomfortable" Read more

"Great shoe, comfortable, elegant, leather.I live outside the United States and they arrived very well" Read more

"...No problem with fit, colors running, slipping, etc. Buying another pair now." Read more

12 customers mention9 positive3 negative

Customers like the leather of the shoes. They mention that the leather soles are wonderful, shiny, sturdy, and have the real leather soul. Some appreciate the classic beefroll details and the quality of the shoe leather.

"These are the real deal! They are shiny, sturdy, have the real leather soul and heel which sound great walking down the hall and they fit great...." Read more

"Great shoe, comfortable, elegant, leather.I live outside the United States and they arrived very well" Read more

"...This is not standard Florsheim quality, weight, texture and quality of shoe leather...." Read more

"...The shoes looked beautiful, leather soles and the wine color was beautiful. They were just to tight...." Read more

162 customers mention71 positive91 negative

Customers are mixed about the fit of the shoes. Some mention that they fit great, comfortable, and true to size, while others say that they run a bit narrow. Some say that the right shoe seems to be a little bigger than the left shoe.

"...It was way too narrow.Thankfully Amazon let me exchange it for the next size up, (11 EEE), which fit fine...." Read more

"Finally I ordered a shoe size larger, different style, and both shoes fit very well." Read more

"...The shoes appeared narrow, but when I tried them on they fit fine (size 10D)...." Read more

"Great classic design, comfortable, fits my husbands ‘ feet perfectly." Read more

98 customers mention55 positive43 negative

Customers are mixed about the durability of the shoes. Some mention that they are well made and excellent quality, while others say that they were poorly made at the toe and not the same quality of shoe they were used to with Florsheim. The soles of these shoes are beginning to separate and fall off after two months.

"These are the real deal! They are shiny, sturdy, have the real leather soul and heel which sound great walking down the hall and they fit great...." Read more

"These were not the same quality of shoe i was used to with Florsheim. They were as stiff as a board when I was used to soft leather...." Read more

"...Nicely made and finished very light shoe." Read more

"...I noticed to my horror that the stitching was coming loose and I could see in between the top of the shoe and the soles...." Read more

27 customers mention15 positive12 negative

Customers are mixed about the value of the shoes. Some mention it's a nice shoe for the price, while others say it'll not be worth the amount. The leather is thin and finished inexpensively.

"Nice shoe for the price,.....but I had to send one pair back, the second pair fit much better...." Read more

"...And they were not the cheapest option, costing almost $140.00. I continued to look for Florsheims, but i eventually had to settle for Nunn Busch." Read more

"Price, quality, namesake punctuality." Read more

"A good shoe, but the leather is thin and finished inexpensively. Does not compare with Johnson and Murphy or Allen Edmonds, but does with Bass...." Read more

15 customers mention0 positive15 negative

Customers are not happy with the stiffness of the shoes. They mention that the leather tops are stiff and can't even hold a shine. The shoes are also very hard soled, and require some break in time. Some say the leather is not as soft as older models, and the soles are not very well cushioned.

"...They were as stiff as a board when I was used to soft leather. The shoes actually looked and felt as if they were made out of plastic...." Read more

"...(probably 30 plus years), this pair seem to have a little thinner leather on the sides and top. Not much, they just seem a little lighter." Read more

"NIcely made shoes, but the soles are not very well cushioned...." Read more

"...The so called leather tops on this shoe is stiff and cant even hold a shine. This shoe was made in Vietnam and I still paid over a hundred dollars...." Read more

Fit as expected
4 Stars
Fit as expected
Hide
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

D Heron
5.0 out of 5 stars My feet are getting larger over the many years. "Said true to size," but I believe too small.
Reviewed in the United States on September 20, 2023
Size: 14 X-WideColor: BlackVerified Purchase
Finally I ordered a shoe size larger, different style, and both shoes fit very well.
Helpful
 Report
Priska
5.0 out of 5 stars Flawless design
Reviewed in the United States on March 10, 2024
Size: 10.5 WideColor: BlackVerified Purchase
Great classic design, comfortable, fits my husbands ‘ feet perfectly.
Helpful
 Report
T. Francis
4.0 out of 5 stars Nice shoe but sizes are random.
Reviewed in the United States on October 25, 2022
Size: 10.5 X-WideColor: BurgundyVerified Purchase
Nice shoe for the price,.....but I had to send one pair back, the second pair fit much better.
I wear a 10 1/2 EE,....every shoe I have is that size.
I ordered a 10 1/2 EEE, (one size wider than I wear based on previous reviews), and couldn't begin to get my foot in it. It was way too narrow.
Thankfully Amazon let me exchange it for the next size up, (11 EEE), which fit fine. Many other customers have had similar experiences based on their reviews.
I really like this shoe.
One person found this helpful
Helpful
 Report
Bradley A. Rindfleisch
5.0 out of 5 stars Old School and LOVE It!
Reviewed in the United States on March 16, 2023
Size: 11.5Color: BlackVerified Purchase
These are the real deal! They are shiny, sturdy, have the real leather soul and heel which sound great walking down the hall and they fit great. They will take a few wears to break in and you may even have to put some band-aids on your achilles, but afterwards, you will love these dress shoes.
One person found this helpful
Helpful
 Report
David A. Jankowski
1.0 out of 5 stars Stiff as a board
Reviewed in the United States on April 20, 2024
Size: 10Color: BlackVerified Purchase
These were not the same quality of shoe i was used to with Florsheim. They were as stiff as a board when I was used to soft leather. The shoes actually looked and felt as if they were made out of plastic. And they were not the cheapest option, costing almost $140.00. I continued to look for Florsheims, but i eventually had to settle for Nunn Busch.
Helpful
 Report
Peter Aull
5.0 out of 5 stars Tight fit broke in in one day polish
Reviewed in the United States on March 31, 2024
Size: 11Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Like 👍👌 more comfortable then flex brown wood taps sound
Helpful
 Report
drb
3.0 out of 5 stars penny loafer revisited
Reviewed in the United States on January 16, 2023
Size: 10Color: BurgundyVerified Purchase
This concerns Florsheim Berkley penny loafers style 17058. I wore such shoes perhaps 60 years ago. That is the context for these comments concerning a pair I recently purchased. I received my purchase in a florsheim shoebox contained in a plastic bag emblazoned with the notice "lighter than our smallest box", a distraction from the fact that the primary purpose of a container is to protect the contents. Fortunately the shoe box was only slightly squashed and the weapon that punctured the top did not penetrate to anything vital. Contents were mostly as one expects for shoes in a shoebox, aside from the tissue packing in the toes being very firmly entrenched. The first thing I noticed is the color, although a reddish brown, it does not look like the cordovan (the color, not the leather) I recall. It seems not as red, or deep, and too uniform. The only markings, are on the inset, and the sole, and under the tongue, which is difficult to see, and where I confirmed the size and found they were made in Vietnam. The shoes appeared narrow, but when I tried them on they fit fine (size 10D). The sewing is not completely uniform, with the most egregious site being the significant intrusion of the beef roll stitching into the interior of the right shoe, on the left side. In the other instances that stitching is (mostly) hidden. The sole is stitched to the moccasin upper/sock. I was expecting I would be able to have the shoes resoled when needed, but I wonder about this construction. The shoe is unlined, which is as I recall.
2 people found this helpful
Helpful
 Report
VVK
5.0 out of 5 stars Fits Like a custom Made Shoe
Reviewed in the United States on December 31, 2023
Size: 9.5 X-WideColor: BurgundyVerified Purchase
All three pairs I ordered, two after receiving and trying the first pair, including the black as well as cordovan/brown have leather soles and are unlined. Fit is snug as is usual with a custom made shoe, 9.5 Wide is tight over the arch as needed for a loafer, shoe box just right for the toes and length of foot. Nicely made and finished very light shoe.
Helpful
 Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
Sech Guerra
5.0 out of 5 stars Excelente compra!
Reviewed in Mexico on August 20, 2023
Size: 9Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Excelente compra
Report
sheunesu
5.0 out of 5 stars Great loafers
Reviewed in Canada on July 10, 2023
Size: 10.5Color: BurgundyVerified Purchase
Fits really well and they look very high class would definitely go great with suit pants.
Report
Florent KONAN
5.0 out of 5 stars Merci
Reviewed in Canada on June 15, 2023
Size: 10.5 WideColor: BlackVerified Purchase
Comme je le voulais.
Merci!
Report
ted marshall
5.0 out of 5 stars Great Penny Loafers!
Reviewed in Canada on June 22, 2022
Size: 8.5Color: BlackVerified Purchase
These Florsheim shoes are about as good as it gets. Great fit and a great looking loafer with of the highest quality leather materials. I highly recommend these shoes!
Report
Joss
4.0 out of 5 stars Les falta plantilla
Reviewed in Mexico on December 26, 2021
Size: 10.5Color: BlackVerified Purchase
Me gusto todo excepto que no tienen plantilla y daña el metatarso
Report