Dunham Men's St. Johnsbury Sandal

4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars 441 ratings
Price: $30.00 $124.95 Free Returns on some sizes and colors
Free 7-day try-on available for some sizes and colors.
Free shipping & returns. Learn more

Brown
Size Chart
US Shoe size
Brand SizeUS
66
6.56.5
77
7.57.5
88
8.58.5
99
9.59.5
1010
10.510.5
1111
11.511.5
1212
1313
1414
1515
1616
1717
1818
1919

Product details

Fabric type
Rubber
Origin
Imported
Sole material
Rubber
Outer material
Leather

About this item

  • Relaxed leather sandal with three points of hook-and-loop adjustability
  • Lightweight ABZORB cushioning
  • Padded backstrap
To buy, select Size

From the manufacturer

dunham shoes, men's boots, wide shoes, men's wide shoes, men's extra wide shoes, outdoor shoes

BOOTS WITH ROOTS—Founded on necessity and driven by curiosity. Born in 1885, inspired by the pioneering spirit of Vermont. Surviving the cold, thriving in the mud and cut from the same character of those who wore them. Reliable, versatile, durable, self-sufficient in every way. Generations have passed but the commitment remains the same. Fit for modern pioneers who pursue life with passion. On the job, at home, in their communities. Building on the lessons of the past to help create a better future. Feet planted firmly on the ground, but never, ever stuck. Fit for any job and ready to get to work.

outdoor shoes, men's shoes, men's wide shoes, men's extra wide shoes,

men's shoes, men's boots, wide shoes, extra wide shoes

men's shoes, men's boots, wide shoes, extra wide shoes

men's shoes, men's boots, wide shoes, extra wide shoes

men's shoes, men's boots, wide shoes, extra wide shoes

VERSATILITY

No matter the occasion or the condition.

DUNHAM FITS

Even hard-to-fit feet deserve the right fit.

HISTORY

Founded by the Dunham brothers in Brattleboro, Vermont.

TECHNOLOGY

Each pair is thoughtfully designed with built-in technologies

Looking for specific info?

Product details

  • Product Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 12.9 x 8 x 4.8 inches; 13 ounces
  • Item model number ‏ : ‎ MCR455SB
  • Department ‏ : ‎ mens
  • Date First Available ‏ : ‎ December 31, 2009
  • Manufacturer ‏ : ‎ Dunham by New Balance
  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B002P8NCJ6
  • Customer Reviews:
    4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars 441 ratings

Product Description

Enjoy the warm weather in style with the Dunham® St. Johnsbury sandals. A padded heel strap features hook-and-loop adjustability and can also be removed to become a slide. Waterproof full grain leather upper features dual hook-and-loop straps with a casual vibe

Comfort is king, as we all know. And you’ll feel like royalty when you strap on this comfortable sandal. The rubber sole and breathable cushioned footbed will support you all day long, while the leather upper features Velcro straps over the foot and around the ankle for a perfect fit. Sounds like a sandal fit for a king.

Customer reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars
4.3 out of 5
441 global ratings

Customers say

Customers like the fit, comfort, adjustability, appearance and value of the sandal. They mention that it suits a very wide and large foot, has comfortable strap padding to prevent chafing and that the 4 way adjustment makes them easy to adjust. They appreciate the simple design and that they look good with no flashy details. They also appreciate the quality and value for money.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews

131 customers mention106 positive25 negative

Customers like the fit of the sandal. They mention that the velcro straps provide a perfect fit, the sandal suits a very wide and large foot, and that the fit was on the money. Some customers also mention that it's narrow enough for their spreading-out feet.

"...The sandal is wide enough for my spreading-out feet. The sandals these are replacing felt like strapping boards to the bottom of my feet...." Read more

"Great fit and comfort. Was a little wary without being able to try them on, but fit perfectly...." Read more

"...These are not pretty by any stretch, but they are a perfect fit for me. I wear the widest width...." Read more

"...making sandals for a Size 15 US foot, I was happy to find these, which fit me fine. There's a bit of arch support, which is a plus for me...." Read more

129 customers mention122 positive7 negative

Customers are satisfied with the comfort of the sandal. They mention that it has great support, comfortable strap padding to prevent chafing, and suede covered memory foam. Some say that the sandals fit comfortably and provide good support.

"...straps and the heel strap are adjusted right, these sandals are really comfortable in spite of not having the cushiest sole/insole...." Read more

"Great fit and comfort. Was a little wary without being able to try them on, but fit perfectly...." Read more

"...Comfort is about equal. There is no difference in cushioning or wear and tear on the feet and legs after long walks...." Read more

"...So I am pleased to report that these are about as comfortable and functional a pair of sandals as I have found for many years...." Read more

88 customers mention65 positive23 negative

Customers like the quality of the sandals. They mention that they are well-made, durable, and reliable. Some say that the sandal is first class and wear well.

"...The sandals lasted the whole day without ever once feeling even slightly uncomfortable...." Read more

"...and the sandals seem reasonably sturdy, although I have just used them at home and on pavement so far..." Read more

"Sturdy, stylish, reliable & well-crafted. My go-to walking sandal for last 20+ years. Highly recommend.👍..." Read more

"...Spring, about three months ago, and now the upper straps on both sandals are wearing through prematurely due to what must be a sharp or rough inner..." Read more

64 customers mention56 positive8 negative

Customers like the value of the sandals. They say they are excellent, functional, and worth the money. They also say the adjustments make them a good solution for people with issues. Customers also say they do their job admirably and are a terrific replacement.

"...those who need arch support; the Propet has an arch support and it works fine...." Read more

"...pleased to report that these are about as comfortable and functional a pair of sandals as I have found for many years...." Read more

"...It is very nice sandal. Size 10 narrow width." Read more

"...Definitely worth the money." Read more

32 customers mention29 positive3 negative

Customers are satisfied with the appearance of the sandal. They mention that it looks good, is comfortable, and has a simple design. Some appreciate the conservative design with no flashy details. Overall, most are happy with the quality and the consistent with photos and description.

"Sturdy, stylish, reliable & well-crafted. My go-to walking sandal for last 20+ years. Highly recommend.👍..." Read more

"This a great looking sandal and provides a lot of comfort." Read more

"...in narrow, and they feel great on my sensitive feet, and they look great...." Read more

"Good quality, consistent with photos and description, quick free delivery. Could be a little more competitively priced...." Read more

20 customers mention20 positive0 negative

Customers find the sandals highly adjustable, with each strap being adjustable. They also appreciate the 4 way adjustment, and the multiple adjustments for different shape feet. The sandals are comfortable and secure on narrow feet.

"Soft, comfortable.Has 3 straps that can be adjusted, most sandals can't adjust rear strap...." Read more

"...insole; very comfortable, and the 4-way adjustment allows you to put your foot where it's the most comfortable in the sandal and fix it there...." Read more

"My husband loves his sandals. They have easy adjustable velcro. Great support and comfort...." Read more

"...There's a bit of arch support, which is a plus for me. Also, each strap is adjustable and if you want to, you can remove the back straps and wear..." Read more

13 customers mention6 positive7 negative

Customers are mixed about the arch support of the sandal. Some mention that there's a bit of support, while others say that there is almost no support.

"...The arch support is decent and the cushioning sufficient...." Read more

"...Some have mentioned that there's not a lot of arch support... I would agree with that. BUT they were still extremely comfortable on my feet...." Read more

"...Gives me a little arch support.Got in narrow width so my heel less likely to slip." Read more

"...The Dunham does not have an arch support but I was able to get my orthodics in place; they stayed and it worked...." Read more

13 customers mention5 positive8 negative

Customers have mixed opinions about the strap of the sandal. Some like the Dunham straps, saying they slide easily through the ring opening. However, others say that the straps come loose and stop working after a few months. The straps fatten up in the middle to prevent them from sliding out of the ring.

"...Well, after a few times near the water they started to come unglued at the front. I assume this had something to do with them getting wet...." Read more

"...The Dunham straps slide easily through the ring opening so that you can lift your foot straight up and then plop straight down when you put them..." Read more

"...They fit fine as is but there's no more strap so if they stretch they'll be too large." Read more

"...The varied straps allow for plenty of adjustment (although they don't look quite so attractive when the velcro is exposed) and the sandals seem..." Read more

Defect Premature Strap Wear Both Sandals
1 Star
Defect Premature Strap Wear Both Sandals
Late last Winter I ordered another pair of Dunham Men's St Johnsbury, Brown, sandals. I started wearing them this Spring, about three months ago, and now the upper straps on both sandals are wearing through prematurely due to what must be a sharp or rough inner surface on the slider rings on both sandals. Seven years ago I purchased the the exact same pair of St Johnsbury sandals. The old pair show no wear in this area even after seven years of constant seasonal use. I would like to exchange them for a new pair that do not have the defective ring. Now, the supplier, Zappos, is playing the "they can't do anything" game because it was sold through Amazon and Amazon is saying they can't do anything because it is Zappos responsibility 30 days after delivery. Back and forth, back and forth. Garbage customer service on a obviously defective product!
Hide
Thank you for your feedback
Sorry, there was an error
Sorry we couldn't load the review

Top reviews from the United States

MaxdB
5.0 out of 5 stars Very comfortable on my old feet
Reviewed in the United States on July 14, 2015
Size: 11 X-WideColor: BrownVerified Purchase
As I've gotten older, my feet have gotten longer and wider. I now wear shoes that are 11, 11.5 or 12 with "wide" or 3E sizing... (used to wear 9.5-10 D, so don't assume your shoe size will stay the same for your whole life, in my 60s now and haven't been able to wear a 9.5 D shoe in 20 years). I debated whether to order these sandals in 11, 11.5, or 12 in one of the widest size options. I after reading some reviews where people said they were pulling the heel strap way in, I decided to try size 11 (wide) first and it was the right choice. The sandal is wide enough for my spreading-out feet. The sandals these are replacing felt like strapping boards to the bottom of my feet. My older feet also like soft cushy soles/insoles... A LOT. And I was a little concerned about reviews that said these sandals were NOT very soft/cushy in the sole/insole, but those reviews said the sandals were comfortable anyway... and that is true. These aren't real cushy on the sole, but the certainly don't feel like boards on the bottom of my feet either. First day wearing them was long "day out" trip... 2 hours of driving, exploring a small town, having lunch, more driving, another couple of hours exploring a preserved old west town, 2 more hours of driving home. Brought comfortable walking shoes and socks in case the sandals weren't comfortable enough to make it through the whole day. The sandals lasted the whole day without ever once feeling even slightly uncomfortable. Have since worn them for several afternoons with the same result. As long as the 2 top straps and the heel strap are adjusted right, these sandals are really comfortable in spite of not having the cushiest sole/insole. I have other sandals with "rubber" insoles that are really uncomfortable and the sandals that feel like boards have smooth leather insoles. These sandals have a suede-like covering on the insole. Another brand of sandal I had with that sort of insole covering wore through the extremely thin suede-like covering very quickly exposing "rubber" underneath. I hope that doesn't happen with these sandals, only time will reveal how durable the insole is, but I've never worn through anything on the insole of other New Balance products I've owned. Some have mentioned that there's not a lot of arch support... I would agree with that. BUT they were still extremely comfortable on my feet. For the review, I debated over 4 or 5 stars, if they had 4.5, I'd give these 4.5 because of the excellent early performance, I wonder if I would have liked them even more with a softer sole/insole. I do have orthotics with arch support and neuroma pads (you'll probably find out about this stuff when you get older too!) that aren't practical to use with sandals, but there's nothing more comfortable than sandals on a summer day. So I really needed something I could wear that offered good foot support without the orthotics and these are working for me so far.
One person found this helpful
Helpful
 Report
Gary Manker
5.0 out of 5 stars Completely positive experience
Reviewed in the United States on June 28, 2023
Size: 12Color: BrownVerified Purchase
Great fit and comfort. Was a little wary without being able to try them on, but fit perfectly. This was a replacement pair for a pair I had bought years ago at a store that no longer carries them. Hence, I ordered them on line with a little trepidation regarding fit, but fit just great. Thanks.
Helpful
 Report
Chaxelle
4.0 out of 5 stars Side by side comparison with the Propet
Reviewed in the United States on June 5, 2013
Size: 9 XX-WideColor: BrownVerified Purchase
I am not a sandal wearer but I busted my big toe and now must wear them. On my first day out I got caught in a rainstorm; it took over a day in direct sun for them to dry out. They are not water resistant. I decided I needed a second pair and ordered in the Propet which is about half the price of the Dunham ($55 vs $95). I now have about 5 walking miles, (2 two and a half mile walks) on each one, several days casual around the house and right now I have the Dunham on one foot and the Propet on the other. Here is the comparison.

The basic designs are almost identical with a three strap system. The 6E Dunham and the 5E Propet both fit fine. I adjusted the rear strap initially and have not had to touch them since. The two top of the foot straps are easy to get in and out of and you can set them tight or loosely and the sandal stays on. The Dunham straps slide easily through the ring opening so that you can lift your foot straight up and then plop straight down when you put them back on. But this does require you to thread the straps back through the rings each time. The Propet can probably do this too but you would have to work at it to slide the strap out of the ring. The straps fatten up in the middle to keep them ifrom sliding out of the ring. This means you don't plop in from the top but rather slide in from the rear which is easy. Take your pick. I prefer the Propet since I do not have to hassle with the rings.

The Propet appears slightly more substantial than the Dunham which is looser with a more relaxed fit, (Propet break in will probably improve this). Comfort is about equal. There is no difference in cushioning or wear and tear on the feet and legs after long walks. From the looks of the sole and cushion, the Propet, may be water resistant but I do not know yet. One big thing for those who need arch support; the Propet has an arch support and it works fine. The Dunham does not have an arch support but I was able to get my orthodics in place; they stayed and it worked.

The big thing is the price. I cannot understand what Dunham thinks they are giving me for twice the price. Price, strapping and arch support is a no brainer win for Propet.
39 people found this helpful
Helpful
 Report
Leanbrit
5.0 out of 5 stars Comfort in a sandal at last
Reviewed in the United States on August 6, 2014
Verified Purchase
I have short, very wide feet (sized 8, 3e or even 4e) and am forever on a quest to find comfortable boots, shoes and sandals. Most of the time I waste money on sandals because they simply don't fit and I shuffle around painfully. So I am pleased to report that these are about as comfortable and functional a pair of sandals as I have found for many years. The varied straps allow for plenty of adjustment (although they don't look quite so attractive when the velcro is exposed) and the sandals seem reasonably sturdy, although I have just used them at home and on pavement so far. The arch support is decent and the cushioning sufficient. I bought them on sale at about $55 and at that price, the relief they offer makes them a bargain for those on the eternal hunt for casual comfort. I even like the mocha color much more than I expected!
Helpful
 Report

Top reviews from other countries

Translate all reviews to English
Neil
5.0 out of 5 stars Quality and Fit
Reviewed in Canada on July 19, 2023
Verified Purchase
I have purchased a number of Dunham products over the years. Excellent quality, with a consistent fit.
Report
Brian A MacElwee
5.0 out of 5 stars Well made
Reviewed in Canada on June 9, 2019
Verified Purchase
Fit good ,cushioning moderate, heel stiff, but I would recommend these to others as my feet may be the problem for perfection
Report
OD
5.0 out of 5 stars Durable and Versatile
Reviewed in Canada on July 22, 2019
Size: 14 X-WideColor: BrownVerified Purchase
I still have my first pair of these, which are about 10 years old, and till use them for working outdoors. Just bought a second pair for all around use. These sandals are super durable and versatile. Highly recommend them.
Report
Lorraine Chartier
5.0 out of 5 stars Pas facile de trouver ces EEEE en boutique
Reviewed in Canada on November 8, 2019
Size: 8 X-WideColor: BrownVerified Purchase
C'était exactement la même sandale que celle que mon mari avait et c'était exactement ce qu'il voulait. Pas facile de trouver des largeurs EEEE dans les boutiques. Parfait!
Report
Alan J Burt
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in Canada on August 2, 2017
Size: 16Color: BrownVerified Purchase
Love them so far
Report